I did my last video teach this past wednesday. I covered the eighth amendment, which states that there shall be no laws enforcing excessive bail, excessive fines, and prohibits cruel and unusual punishments. I wanted to break up the students up into groups of three however, due to the number of students groups of four ended up working out better. I gave each group one packet of group notes. I handed out a set of group resources, which they were supposed to read and then use to answer the questions on the group notes. We covered excessive fines and bail with my packets and then the death penalty covered the last question in my packet and the first question in Ms. B’s packet. It sounds complicated, but it really wasn’t.
The second period class crashed. I met resistance from students just to get into groups. I had to state to one student, “Are you really going to give me a hard time about getting into groups?” As we went throughout the lesson, the assigned readers kept getting off task, some students said they “didn’t feel like reading”, it was frustrating. I ended up reading most of the material because the groups kept getting off task. After the class I needed time to chill out and calm down because I was so upset. Several students went out of their way to avoid doing any work. Those that did the work refused to talk about the questions provided on the guided notes or that I asked them. Even when I provided the answers some groups were talking and would not quiet down when I tried to get the students refocused.
Then 4th period came and saved the day. I made some adjustments. I decided to cut out some of the material and to read the examples of excessive fines and bail, then when when I asked the questions on the group notes great discussions developed. It was completely opposite from 2nd period. There were actually a couple of times where I had to cut the debates/discussion short in order to cover the needed material. It was how I planned how the lesson would work out. I felt redeemed and much more successful with my second class.
I think there were several key differences in the two classes. The biggest difference was the students. 2nd period just didn’t want to work. I felt like perhaps I was doing something wrong, but the more I observed Ms. B teaching both 2nd and 4th period I’ve realized that 2nd period just has several lethargic students. There have been times when we will discuss a topic, cover some new information, and a question will be asked about what was covered in the discussion and no one will answer the question. They know the answer, they just don’t want to answer or talk. The second difference was the amount of information I threw at the students, it was most likely too much. The students probably felt overwhelmed. In the future I will use the philosophy that in most cases, less is more.